Affiliate disclosure: This article contains affiliate links. We may earn a commission if you purchase through them, at no additional cost to you.
Quick verdict: SmartSHIELD 3 mm XPE roll vs Noico Red 4 mm PE sheets
SmartSHIELD 118-mil aluminum-faced XPE foam and Noico Red 150-mil closed-cell PE foam are two adhesive-backed automotive thermal/acoustic liner options, not identical butyl-constrained-layer vibration dampers. The original SmartSHIELD ASIN B0BBP8SWB3 is associated with a 3-mm, 16-inch-wide × 28-ft roll, marketed as 36 sq ft. The original Noico ASIN B07TKXMPH7 matches Noico Red NR3004D, 4 mm, 34 pieces, marketed 36 sq ft. Differences in thickness, shape, thermal documentation and installation waste matter more than an untested promise of full cabin soundproofing.
Important math: the SmartSHIELD seller advertises both a 16-in × 28-ft roll and 36 sq ft of coverage. The uncut geometric rectangle calculates to (16 ÷ 12) × 28 = 37.33 sq ft, not exactly 36. The difference may represent nominal usable coverage, rounding or a seller specification error; the underlying reason has not been verified. Plan on the marketed 36 sq ft until the supplier confirms the exact supplied length/width. This is not evidence of extra guaranteed material.
Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Both original Amazon product links below are sponsored and may earn a commission without extra cost.
Original commercial destinations: SmartSHIELD original B0BBP8SWB3 — verify 3-mm selection and Noico Red B07TKXMPH7 — verify 36-sq-ft selection. These preserved saved PADO routes do not establish current Amazon seller stock, shipping or checkout details.
SmartSHIELD 118 mil: 3-mm aluminum-faced XPE foam roll

The original-ASIN-linked SmartSHIELD retailer entry identifies B0BBP8SWB3 as an adhesive-backed closed-cell aluminum + XPE foam + glue liner, with advertised 118 mil / 0.118 inch / 3 mm thickness and 16-in × 28-ft roll dimensions. It advertises a 215°F operating-temperature statement. These are retailer-supplied specifications, not independently measured foam or adhesive heat endurance.
The Insulation MarketPlace brand product collection includes separate SmartSHIELD 3-mm, 5-mm and thicker foam products. That range is not a reason to substitute a separate 5-mm or non-aluminum film variant for the saved 3-mm comparison ASIN. We have not matched a specific current first-party maker product page to B0BBP8SWB3; original-ASIN seller records support the identified 3-mm family rather than a maker-authenticated unique batch number.
SmartSHIELD’s roll format may be convenient for long, accessible interior panels where one can measure and cut a continuous strip. The reflective aluminum facing and XPE construction make it a liner, not the same material as a dense butyl-and-foil constrained-layer sheet whose main role is damping resonant metal. Closed-cell foam can act as a compliant separator, but it should not be treated as a heavy mass barrier or an independently fire-rated engine-exhaust shield.
Read the published SPD SmartSHIELD product review for its material role and installation cautions. The original tracked product route remains the exact SmartSHIELD 118-mil 3-mm ASIN, not a separate similarly named 5-mm option.
Noico Red 150 mil: maker-identified 4-mm PE foam sheets

Noico’s official Red 150-mil product page identifies the NR3004D variant as 4-mm closed-cell polyethylene (PE), with 34 sheets measuring nominal 15.7 × 9.8 inches, sold as 36 sq ft. The page URL includes the older string “170-mil,” but its visible product specification clearly says 150 mil / 4 mm; use the specification, not the historical URL wording. The nominal geometry 34 × 15.7 × 9.8 ÷ 144 ≈ 36.32 sq ft, broadly consistent with the marketed 36-sq-ft package.
The original-ASIN retailer record associates B07TKXMPH7 with NR3004D / GTIN 00857195006405, 4-mm material and 36-sq-ft coverage. A different indexed seller sometimes titles a B07TKXMPH7 result as 18 sq ft while exposing an 18-sq-ft part NR3004_New; that appears to conflate separate Noico variants, so confirm the selected GTIN and 34-sheet pack rather than assuming every retailer title is reliable.
Noico specifies a product operating-temperature ceiling of 190°F and explicitly says the Red foam is not for mufflers, catalytic converters, particulate filters or other exhaust surfaces requiring purpose-made high-temperature materials. Its first-party listing distinguishes this PE liner from the maker’s separate 80-mil butyl vibration damper and separate 18-sq-ft pack. Review the published SPD Noico Red source page for the existing family context.
Original preserved commercial destination: Noico Red 150-mil original 36-sq-ft ASIN — confirm NR3004D.
Side-by-side buyer specifications
| Product factor | SmartSHIELD 118-mil XPE | Noico Red 150-mil PE |
|---|---|---|
| Original saved ASIN | B0BBP8SWB3 | B07TKXMPH7 |
| Material description | Aluminum-facing + XPE closed-cell foam + self-adhesive backing (retailer) | PE closed-cell foam with adhesive (maker) |
| Nominal thickness | 118 mil / about 3 mm | 150 mil / about 4 mm |
| Pack shape | Seller says 16-in × 28-ft roll | 34 sheets, 15.7 × 9.8 in each |
| Advertised area | 36 sq ft; roll rectangle calculates 37.33 sq ft; reconcile at purchase | 36 sq ft; nominal rectangles about 36.32 sq ft |
| Temperature statement | Seller states up to 215°F; maker test not independently verified | Maker states up to 190°F; not for exhaust contact |
| Variant documentation | Original ASIN seller, no exact first-party batch page obtained | Original ASIN, maker NR3004D, GTIN 00857195006405 |
| Matched acoustic performance test | Not obtained | Not obtained |
Although Noico is nominally 1 mm thicker, that does not prove greater installed noise isolation or temperature performance. A roll can create fewer seams on long accessible panels; smaller sheets can be easier around complex door geometry. Thickness, area and temperature ceiling are product-selection data rather than a measured comparative dB ranking.
Installation and safety
Determine whether your vehicle problem is a hard-contact rattle, ringing thin metal, an open air-leak path or an under-carpet thermal discomfort problem. Fix loose trim and failing seals first. For suitable liner treatment, remove dirt and moisture, check approved substrate and adhesive compatibility, keep drainage holes, window mechanisms, restraint-system deployment paths, wiring, latches and service openings unobstructed, and follow vehicle/manufacturer installation instructions.
Do not install either generic liner directly against catalytic converters, mufflers, exhaust headers or other high-temperature components. The stated 215°F versus 190°F limits come from different source types and are not an independently matched heat-endurance test. No certificate of fire approval or guaranteed adhesive service life for a specific vehicle has been confirmed.
Choose SmartSHIELD when its exact original 3-mm aluminum/XPE roll is appropriate for long interior pieces and the chosen retailer confirms its pack dimensions. Choose Noico Red when the maker-identified 4-mm, 34-sheet NR3004D package fits the vehicle layout and you prefer smaller cuts. Confirm thickness and useful area before purchase rather than assuming either advertised 36-sq-ft pack will cover precisely 36 sq ft after trimming.
Frequently asked questions
Why does a 16-inch by 28-foot roll advertise 36 square feet?
The nominal rectangle is 37.33 sq ft. The supplier gives 36 sq ft of marketed coverage without explaining the difference. Plan using verified delivered dimensions and allow offcuts; do not invent a manufacturer correction.
Is Noico Red 150 mil actually a 170-mil product?
The original maker webpage retains “170-mil” in its URL, but its visible specifications state 150 mil (4 mm). Those are the figures used here.
Does B07TKXMPH7 definitely ship the 36-sq-ft pack?
The first-party NR3004D product and multiple exact-ASIN retailer records describe 36 sq ft, but a conflicting 18-sq-ft reseller title exists. Confirm the 34-sheet NR3004D selection and retailer pack at checkout.
Are these butyl vibration-damping mats?
No. They are described as thin closed-cell foam liners. A constrained-layer butyl damper, a heavy barrier and an absorbent foam address different mechanical/acoustic processes.
Can either make road noise disappear?
No. An installation could improve a specific contact or heat issue, but neither supplier provides a controlled same-vehicle test proving universal elimination of road, wind or tire noise.
Evidence and recommendation
Evidence: original-ASIN SmartSHIELD retailer record, maker-brand SmartSHIELD product categories (not a direct exact-ASIN certification), Noico’s manufacturer NR3004D specifications, an original Noico-ASIN retailer record, and the two published SPD source reviews. Neither material was instrumented for noise reduction by SPD and live Amazon checkout, selected seller inventory and shipping were not verified.
SPD’s recommendation: use the known manufacturer model NR3004D for a thicker 4-mm pre-cut PE liner or the original SmartSHIELD 3-mm XPE roll when continuous fitting is desirable. The saved original product identities are qualified; resolve the area and retailer-pack details when buying.
Good luck and happy soundproofing!