Siless Underfelt vs Noico Red: Fabric Finish or Foam?

Siless Black Underfelt Carpet and Noico Red 150 mil Liner are not two interchangeable sound-deadening mats. Siless is a black nonwoven polyester finishing fabric, marketed as one approximately 59 × 122-inch, 50 sq ft sheet for speaker enclosures and interior trim. Noico Red is self-adhesive, approximately 4 mm closed-cell polyethylene foam, sold as 34 pieces and 36 sq ft to address vehicle thermal insulation and some acoustic decoupling. Their installation methods and acoustic roles are materially different.

Evidence basis: The original two Amazon ASINs, Siless’s exact-ASIN retailer product table, Noico Red’s matched technical description and the site’s two published source reviews were used. No independent finished-cabin noise measurement, certified heat barrier test or fire-assembly rating is claimed in this review.

First decide: visible finish or insulating layer?

A speaker-box or trunk fabric is selected mainly for surface finish, wear, appearance and ease of cutting and bonding around irregular shapes. A closed-cell foam liner can provide cushioning, some thermal resistance and interface decoupling behind appropriate trim. The polyester carpet does not become a heavy sound-blocking membrane by being advertised as “soundproofing”; a 4 mm polyethylene foam does not become a mass-loaded vinyl barrier simply because a seller calls it “deadening.”

Siless Black Underfelt: one wide nonwoven finishing sheet

Existing SPD Siless black polyester underfelt carpet sheet source-review image for speaker boxes and vehicle interior finishing
Correct site-owned Siless underfelt product-review image, distinct from the brand’s 80 mil butyl mats.

An ASIN-specific Siless listing matches the original B0C7TW4RX1 to model C01 from Bema Group, described as one black polyester sheet 59 × 122 inches with glue-down installation. The listed area is about 49.88 sq ft, although a direct geometric calculation 59 × 122 ÷ 144 ≈ 49.99 sq ft. That small difference may reflect nominal dimensions, rounding or a seller convention and is not evidence of a large under-shipment.

Nonwoven carpet can make a subwoofer box, trunk surface or display panel look consistent, cover raw edges and provide some abrasion resistance when correctly mounted. It is not documented as a dense acoustic barrier or as having an independent material-specific NRC, STC or heat transmission rating for this exact SKU. Its adhesive is a separate selection: make sure the glue is compatible with fabric, substrate and the environmental conditions rather than assuming this sheet has peel-and-stick backing.

It can be stretched or cut around corners depending on the fabric, but seams, glue bleed-through and shrinkage or detachment should be considered. In cars, keep all ventilation slots, electronic components, seatbelt mechanisms and safety devices accessible. See the SPD underfelt carpet review and the unchanged original Siless underfelt Amazon route.

Noico Red 150 mil: adhesive closed-cell PE foam

Existing SPD Noico Red 150 mil self-adhesive polyethylene foam automotive liner product-review image
Noico Red source-review media associated with the 34-sheet 36 sq ft foam liner, not a decorative carpet.

An original-ASIN-matched Noico record identifies B07TKXMPH7 as a 150 mil / approximately 4 mm thick self-adhesive closed-cell polyethylene foam product marketed in a 36 sq ft package, with 34 sheets of around 15.7 × 9.8 inches. The nominal geometry (34 × 15.7 × 9.8 ÷ 144 ≈ 36.32 sq ft) agrees closely with its rounded area claim, unlike treating a carpet sheet dimension as an insulation capacity.

A second ASIN-specific reseller technical description notes the manufacturer-stated operating limit of approximately 190°F / 88°C and explicitly warns against using the product as a heat shield at exhaust, catalytic converters or diesel particulate filters. That distinction matters: an interior liner may provide an insulating layer where temperatures and installation conditions permit, but neither its color nor self-adhesive backing certifies safe high-temperature use.

Noico is described as a practical second layer in some interior constructions after suitable metal damping, particularly when thermal comfort or trim-to-panel contact is a problem. It is not evidence that the same thin foam blocks all road noise, and it does not cure door leaks or mechanical rattles. Use the published Noico Red source review and the original Noico Red Amazon selection to verify model and package.

Quick comparison

Buyer criterion Siless Black Underfelt Noico Red 150 mil
Original ASIN B0C7TW4RX1 B07TKXMPH7
Material and role Polyester decorative finishing carpet Closed-cell PE thermal/decoupling liner
Pack configuration One 59 × 122-inch fabric sheet 34 adhesive 15.7 × 9.8-inch sheets
Nominal material area About 50 sq ft 36 sq ft
Thickness Exact independently rated carpet thickness not established 150 mil / ~4 mm
Mounting method Separate compatible glue Self-adhesive backing
Special caution Appearance and substrate glue compatibility Not rated as an exhaust heat shield
Same-assembly measured sound isolation Not established Not established

The Siless material has a larger nominal flat sheet area, but 50 ÷ 36 ≈ 1.39 compares textile surface with foam surface, not competing amounts of the same material. It does not show Siless to be 39% better or cheaper acoustically. An interior finishing sheet and a thermal lining layer may both be relevant in a multi-layer project, subject to adhesive compatibility and safe packaging, but they address different steps.

How to choose

Choose Siless if the immediate work is covering a wooden speaker cabinet, lining a trunk trim face or achieving a black fabric finish. Choose Noico Red when you need a thin adhesive foam insulation/decoupling layer on a compatible interior surface within the specified temperature limits. If the underlying problem is resonant bare metal, a correctly designed butyl constrained-layer mat may be a different first product to consider.

Measure, cut a test section, check bond strength and avoid wrapping materials over service fasteners, drains, seatbelt mounts or active vehicle controls. Noico’s operating-temperature warning deserves particular attention anywhere near exhaust-adjacent components.

Frequently asked questions

Is Siless Underfelt the same as Siless 80 mil butyl mat?

No. This ASIN is a polyester fabric intended mainly as a finishing layer, not the company’s adhesive butyl vibration-damping sheet.

Can Noico Red be used as a catalytic converter heat shield?

No. The product’s documented temperature warning explicitly rules out that application.

Why is the Siless size listed as both 49.88 and 49.99 sq ft?

The reseller quotes 49.88 while multiplying the rounded outer dimensions gives approximately 49.99. Treat both as nominal descriptions of a roughly 50 sq ft sheet.

Does either improve door isolation by a guaranteed number of decibels?

No independent installed door isolation test for either product was established in this comparison.

SPD’s decision

These are different material categories. Siless is the option for visible fabric finishing; Noico Red is the option for a self-adhesive closed-cell foam liner where its thermal and fit constraints are satisfied. Do not rank them as if they were identical soundproofing mats.

Affiliate disclosure: Both original Amazon product links are affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Good luck and happy soundproofing!